St. Ambrose computer science major George Coin continues his four-part series, “AI at Ambrose,” with a focus on life outside the classroom. He asks students and faculty when they turn to chatbots, how much they trust the answers and what they choose to keep private.
Graphic Courtesy of Sophie Schillie
How AI Fits Into Daily Life at SAU
When Senior Computer Science major Luke Mirr went looking for skis, he had two questions. What kind would suit a beginner, and where could he find a deal? He says he asked ChatGPT, which gave him several options and pointed him to a site with last year’s models at about half price.
“I think it just gives me more information to begin with,” Mirr says. He says he’s used the same approach to find cheap flights and checks the suggestions himself if an answer makes him skeptical.
A chatbot needs some information to narrow a search. Mirr says he’s comfortable asking what gear would suit a beginner, but he would keep his financial records, home address and phone number out of a chat. He says he wonders what happens to his conversations on the company’s servers after he deletes them from his history.
Mirr says he limits the personal information he shares with AI and leaves relationship questions out of his chats. A chatbot is “not a real person,” he says. “It just doesn’t know the whole spectrum of the situation.”
For students and faculty at St. Ambrose, even a practical question can involve sharing something personal. To help plan an outing, a chatbot might need to know where someone is, how much they can spend or who is coming along.
Planning a Birthday From Afar
Senior Business Marketing major Esteban Rocha says he turned to a chatbot to help plan a birthday outing from a distance. His girlfriend was visiting Montreal with her mother and barely knew the city.
After looking into the area, Rocha says he found that the weather in Montreal was poor, so he asked the chatbot for activities his girlfriend and her mother could do despite the weather, then used its suggestions to put together a plan for the day.
Rocha says he also uses AI to find restaurants and get ideas for meals he can cook. Since opening a restaurant with his uncle, he says he’s used AI to design and edit flyers and create videos advertising the business.
When an answer leaves him unsure, Rocha says he sometimes asks a second chatbot the same question. If the answers line up, he says, he takes that as a sign he may be on the right track. When it comes to sensitive personal matters, Rocha says a chatbot’s advice tends to be general because it doesn’t know how the person asking feels.
“If you really need help, I don’t think AI is going to be the best solution,” Rocha says. He says he worries that when people turn to a chatbot for advice they once sought from friends or family, they lose the conversations that help them stay connected.
According to an article from The Washington Post, a four-week study by MIT and OpenAI found that participants who used ChatGPT more often reported less social interaction with other people.
Deciding What to Share
Sophomore Human performance & fitness major Daniel Maas says he turns to AI to check the weather, figure out how to split up his workouts and brainstorm ideas for art projects. It can be tempting to ask out of habit, he says, especially when he knows he can get an answer quickly.
“I use AI kind of as like a foundation,” Maas says. When he wants to investigate a question more closely, he says he likes to “branch off into other resources.”
Maas says he feels comfortable telling a chatbot whether he wants to gain or lose weight but would leave out details about his relationships. “I do not check the privacy settings,” he says. He says he worries about what data AI services retain and tries to be careful about what he types. He also says he feels uneasy about a company using his conversations to build a profile of him.
Junior Secondary Education major Rylie Frazelle says she uses AI to find out what flights look like around the dates she has in mind or which destinations might be cheaper. When she hasn’t settled on a destination, she says she asks questions like, “What’s the cheapest place to go during this time?”
Frazelle says she would keep personal financial information like bank statements and sensitive health details out of those conversations. When asked how much she knows about what AI services do with her conversations, she says, “My understanding is very low.”
She says she still uses AI for quick questions and wants to know more about where her information goes and how companies use it.
The Washington Post reviewed 47,000 ChatGPT conversations that users shared by link and that anyone could read in the Internet Archive. In one, a user asked for help filing a police report after saying their husband had threatened their life. The chat included the user’s name, home address and their children’s names.
Checking What the Chatbot Remembers
SAU Computer Science Professor Ally Limke says she’s asked AI for places to eat and things to do on vacation, with details such as how much she wants to spend or whether an activity would be relaxing. If she has just 30 minutes free, she says she can ask for ideas that leave time to get there.
“I want some level of privacy,” Limke says. She says she looks for settings that let her opt out of having her chats used to train AI models and enables them when she can. Even with those settings in place, she says she keeps her name and address out of her prompts and avoids sharing photos of herself or her family when she uses AI to generate images.
Limke says she occasionally checks what the tool has learned about her “to make sure I’m not oversharing.” She says it reminds her of the profiles that search and social media companies build from people’s activity. “It feels invasive,” she says.
Limke says she also worries about what happens when people routinely ask a chatbot to simplify everything they read. She says she likes using it to break down unfamiliar ideas and thinks readers need practice working through new vocabulary and complex arguments on their own.
If the tool went away, Limke says she would miss “getting the personalized answers.” When she asks how to fill half an hour on vacation, she says a few details about her plans make the answer more useful. Checking what the chatbot remembers, she says, helps her decide how much to tell it the next time.
In the December issue of the Buzz, George concludes “AI at Ambrose” with a look at how AI is changing the labor market, from what employers look for in new hires to how the work itself may change for students after graduation.
Catch up on the series with AI in the SAU Classroom: Who’s Doing the Thinking? and SAU Faculty Weigh AI’s Place in the Classroom.